Long Island's Attraction of the Year
Looking for Long Island's best Halloween Fun? Then you'll want to check out our Haunted Hall of Fame, featuring Long Island's Favorite Haunted Houses from years past! LIHauntedHouses.com's Attraction of the Year winners were voted on by thrill seekers like YOU - so you know they're a ton of fun, and packed with big scares!
Do you know of an amazing Long Island haunt that you think should be in LIHauntedHouses.com's Haunted Hall of Fame? Make sure to leave them a review on this site! The more reviews a haunt has the better the chances of being nominated Haunt of the Year.
Did you visit one of our haunted attractions and really enjoyed it? Then leave us some feedback to help us determine our Long Island Attraction of the Year!
2024 Winner
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
2024 Nominees
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
East Meadow House of Horror
East Meadow, NY
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
Halloween House Long Island
Hicksville, NY
2023 Nominees
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
Halloween House Long Island
Hicksville, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
East Meadow House of Horror
East Meadow, NY
Ruth Place Haunt
Plainview, NY
Haunted Hollow
Calverton, NY
2022 Nominees
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
2021 Nominees
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2019 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2019 Nominees
Cemetery of Lost Souls (PERMANENTLY CLOSED)
Massapequa Park, NY
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
Haunted Hollow
Calverton, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
2018 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2018 Nominees
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Challenge Escape Rooms - Halloween Editions
Franklin Square, NY
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
2017 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2017 Nominees
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Spooky Fest at The Center for Science, Teaching & Learning
Rockville Centre, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
RISE of the Jack O'Lanterns - Long Island
Wheatley Heights, NY
Cemetery of Lost Souls (PERMANENTLY CLOSED)
Massapequa Park, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
2016 Nominees
Restless Souls Haunted House Complex
Huntington Station, NY
Take on four haunted attractions at one great location! This haunt also doubles as a fundraiser for the West Hills United Methodist Church in Huntington Station.
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Bayville Scream Park offers six heart-pounding attractions, including Temple of Terror, The Cage, Evil in the Woods, Curse of the Zombie Pirates, Bloodworth Haunted Mansion and Uncle Needle's Funhouse of Fear in 3D!
Spooky Fest at The Center for Science, Teaching & Learning
Rockville Centre, NY
Celebrate the Halloween Season at The Center for Science Teaching and Learning and enjoy a Spooky Walk through the woods and take on The Maze of Zombies, along with family-friendly fun, too!
Deepwells Haunted Mansion 'FREAK SHOW’
Saint James, NY
Deepwell's Mansion is rumored to have some ghostly activity, and during the Halloween Season, it is transformed into a horrifying haunt for locals to brave.
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
Delivering scares for over five years, the Yaphank Trail of Terror takes 15 minutes to complete and in addition to the trail, visitors can enjoy a movie, bonfire and concession stand!
2015 Winner
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
2015 Nominees
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
2014 Nominees
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
Yaphank Trail of Terror
Yaphank, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
2013 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2013 Nominees
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Haunted Hallways
Centereach, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Adventureland's Nightmare on the Midway
Farmingdale, NY
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
2012 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2012 Nominees
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
2011 Winner
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
2011 Nominees
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
2010 Nominees
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Haunted Hallways
Centereach, NY
Darkness Rising
Copiague, NY
Bayville Scream Park
Bayville, NY
2009 Nominees
Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
Bellport, NY
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
2008 Nominees
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
2007 Nominees
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY
2006 Nominees
Schmitt's Farm Haunt
Melville, NY