Gateway's Haunted Playhouse
2013 Haunt of the Year Nominee
2012 Haunt of the Year Nominee
2011 Haunt of the Year Nominee
2010 Haunt of the Year Nominee
2009 Haunt of the Year Nominee
Professional actors, make-up artists and designers from Long Island’s oldest professional theatre have won this attraction numerous “Best Haunt” awards. Voted #1 on Long Island by News12, named to USA Today’s list of “Top Ten Haunted Houses in New York," one of the Best Haunted Attractions in the USA by HauntWorld.com. Refreshments available. Recommended for mature audiences.
Share your Scares!
- PLUS -
Not So Scary Adventure for Kids Oct. 11 - Nov 1
Sat & Sun afternoons from noon-4pm
$10 admission includes guided walk-through, Pumpkin Bouncer, Face Painting, Balloons, and more! Email Haunt Owner
Recent ReviewsReview This Haunt
Definitely got your moneys worth
Overall experience wasn't terrible, but could have been better. A couple that was ahead of our small group got the most enjoyment, but ruined the "spook" and creepy" aspect of it that we all wanted. The props were interesting and had the smells and sites matched perfectly. Total wait time was about 20-25 minutes, and the attraction felt like it was about 30-40 minutes itself. There were a lot of dead points that could have had more activity also.Posted 10/31/14
Best on long island
This was the best one I have been to on long island. Have been to many of the haunted houses around here. But this one was the best,at probably 25 minutes from entry to exit. The actors were committed to the work, they put full effort into scaring. The environment and decor of are top notch, to the point even some rooms actually smell horrible to match the props.this is a must experience.Posted 10/30/14
From Haunter to Haunter
Ok, Halloween is my favorite time of the year and I never feel complete without going to a haunted house. Working in one I don't have the luxury of going to one on the weekends. Being that you were opened on one of our off nights was a God sent cause I finally got to visit the haunted playhouse. First off, your sets are amazing. I knew it was going to be great because of your sets, The maze, the layout, the long walk through made it top notch just from those alone. It made it go longer, it was spookier, and made it visually and psychologically amazing and worth it. I was blown away from all the new surprise elements. Actors were great. Characters were creative but the makeup lacked. We went on an off night, but I'm sure y'all rock it on the weekends. I was hoping for more but the ones that were good, they were good. The kid actors added to it for sure. You fulfilled my haunting hunger and I will be back. I can't wait to see what you guys have in store for the future and hope you continue to develop. coming from another haunter, major props. A must see and deserve the recognition.Posted 10/29/14
Best Haunted House
You will not be disappointed! It's really a great haunted house, ism impress with all the labor that they put into that house.Posted 10/20/14
Really long and that's about it
Gateway was a big disappointment this year. The actors really aren't great, most of them are in mediocre makeup and they just stare at you. There's not nearly enough jump scares or anything scary happening period. You can tell that they put a lot of work into it but I can't help but feel letdown regardless. Maybe Gateway should focus on making a smaller and scarier haunt instead of just dragging it out when nothing really interesting happensPosted 10/14/14
0 out of 1 found this review helpful
Wow!!!!! I do not scare easily AT ALL but this scared the crap out of me!!! They really put you in some scary situations! At numerous points in the walk I had to run as fast as I could leaving my party behind to bypass the room completely because I was terrified! The actors and actresses are pretty scary as well but the actual physical situations you are put in room to room are super scary! You have to experience this!Posted 10/8/14
Very well done!
This attraction is set up well. You don't have to wait on a long irritating line. You can just hang around, enjoy some hot apple cider and other fall things! When your number is called you just go right in with your group. As for the actual house, it was very good! There are many changes in scenery and the actors are very good too. I didn't think it was that scary but this is coming from the person that goes to sleep watching horror films. The rest of my friends thought it was pretty scary! Some place I'd probably come back to!Posted 10/8/14
I can't believe I've never heard of this place before! That said, I can't wait to go back next year (or who am I kidding, maybe a second round this season). Our group had actually gone to a different LI haunted house an hour before this one and we were pretty disappointed. Well let me tell you, there's no comparison. The actors, makeup, scenery, and entire experience were amazing. The walk through is easily 30 minutes as we were told. I thought it was very well organized and we only passed another group once from a distance so it really felt like we had the place to ourselves. And I loved that while we waited for our group to be called, there was a whole outdoor area with food, a bar, and a DJ to pass the time. As someone who loves Halloween and anything horror, I was impressed. Great job Gateway!Posted 10/5/14
Coming Back!! Best ever!!
This year I went to the haunted house in previews, on a friday. I shouldn't have gone during previews, though. I heard from a worker that it was only 70% done. It was AMAZING for only 70%!!!! I would have never known. I am coming back to see what this wonderful, insane masterpiece is in it's entierty. My favorite part was when I was walking in a maze thingy and I had to go on a school bus. I think the kids are super talented. Also, I liked the weird nurse lady. Tell her that she is horrific if you see this!! I have been to many haunts all over new york, but this one is certainly the best by far. Everything about it, from the adults, to the kids, to the sets, Gateway is the best even in previews!!Posted 10/1/14
Usually the best, we still love you though!
This is the ONLY haunt we we cannot wait for every year. Always impressed with the actors and realistic themes. We went on opening weekend because it was almost half price. I must say the theme was a great idea, we did have fun but it seemed to lack something. We walked forever without seeing any actors at all. Usually it's packed with scares around every corner, this year it seemed to be a little boring. Much of the sets were the same as last year but many more animatronics. I won't say it was horrible this year but we were definitely disappointed. Hopefully next year they will come back and be better than ever. Maybe this year was just a fluke because 2013 was the best EVER. Still love Gateway and would recommend the visit, it beats out most haunts, even at it's worse!Posted 9/29/14
I went with my boyfriend and it was awesome. We were both scared and screaming! The actors throughout the entire house we're incredible. We will definitely be back next year! We can't wait to see what The Gateway has in store next year. Thank you for an awesome scare!Posted 10/30/13
Gateway is always number 1!
Gateway is the best haunted house i have ever been to! You will not be disappointed! i suggest you go on a week night this way you will not waste time waiting on a line. They are a theater usually and are able to use their crew to create this elaborate haunted house. Everything has been throughly researched and goes with the story line that changes yearly. Also your experience changes nightly. I went 3 nights in a row and each experience was completely different. I have acted in a haunted house before and know the tricks and i still left having screamed and jumped through out the whole haunt. Also its $30 for 30 minutes of haunting and if you think about it that way its really not that extensive besides the fact its totally worth it. And you can get discounts if you buy tickets on their website. So all in all best haunted house ever!!!!! Keep it going Gateway!!!Posted 10/29/13
One of the Best Haunted Houses I have ever been to
I've been going to Gateways Hauted House for about 4 years now and it changes evey year and it never disapoints us. The props, the actors and spooky story makes it by far one of the best haunted houses there is and I've been to many all over the USA.Posted 10/29/13
what used to be great is now mediocre
In past years this has always been one of my favorites, but this year they lost a step. The story line was confusing, the actors were unenthusiastic and untrained. The biggest problem was the shear volume of peoplethey try to push through the haunt. How are you supposed to be scaired or startled when you see whats going to happen when it happens to the group in front of you? I believe they had over a 1000 vistors the night I atrended with the average cost being $30... thats $30000 a night. Slow it down gateway, people are paying good money for the event...do 700 guests instead, youll still make your money. Also give your actors some training make it worth the drive and the moneyPosted 10/28/13
Not horrible, but not amazing
I definitely enjoyed myself going through Gateway. The sets are very elaborate and they make the best use of their space, but unfortunately the actors aren't up to par. There was very little interaction from them; most of them would just stand there and not say a single word or utter a noise at all. The make-up was also very minimalistic.Posted 10/27/13
Really Scary...read on..
Anyone looking for a REALLY SCARY Haunted House to visit for the Halloween season should check out Gateways Haunted Playhouse in Bellport. I went with my kids tonight and OMG!!!! It was REALLY SCARY for sure. It was voted #1 Haunted House on LI and they deliver. Trust me if my daughter did not lead us through I would still be in there somewhere. Have Fun!!Posted 10/24/13
Better every year!
This year was great! Scared me good! Actors, props, effects rocked! Only one criticism: tell the actors to NOT scream directly in patron's ears! It's not scary; it's simply infuriating and, quite frankly, painful to the ear. Otherwise, kudos to all for a great haunt!Posted 10/24/13
Well done and professional
This haunted house was so put together unlike the usual hole in the walls throughout Long Island and even NYC. I has a couple of good scares and was so impressed with the set up. It's at least 35 minutes and had so many actor everywhere. I love the waiting area set- up and the professional employees. It's so worth the money! Go there, you won't be disappointed. Good time, forget the restPosted 10/24/13
My daughter son-inlaw 17 yr old granddaughter my husband and myself went this past weekend. We feel it rates up there amongst the plays gateway provides.Haunted house was much larger than we thought and superb. A must goPosted 10/22/13
GET HERE NOW!!!! Amazing Haunted House!
I heard about this Haunted House, I am from Maine and have been to Haunted Houses all over the country. I decided to head to Long Island to check this one out after hearing all about it. I want to start by describing the waiting experience. Although the wait times vary, it was well worth it and the wait went fast because of the actors outside. They were so professional and stayed in character superbly. They could use maybe 2-3 more out there due to the large crowds. When you walk into the house you walk up steps and immediately notice the theme of Grimm's Fairy Tales. Walking through what seemed to be an old attic was so creepy. You then enter the outside part of the maze. There is a room with what appears to be a man lady and as he is distracting you a frantic male pops out and is extremely scary. You continue through the maze and arrive at different characters. You then enter a door and get inside the house. The different rooms were amazing and the precise detail is insane. There are heavy bags that appear to be bodies. They are so realistic. You enter a mine and there are a couple people. The mine was probably one of the creepiest parts. You hear whistling and the scares are endless. A boy scares you into a pitch black hallway. The pitch black hallway is the best part. I'm not going to give it away but it is awesome. You are scared into a room of young screaming children and led throughout the rest of the haunt. The effects are insane and the cast is amazing. The makeup and set is so amazing. The makeup is very detailed and looks so cool. Very long path almost 35 minutes! Awesome scares. Well worth the trip. Definitely one of the best Haunted Houses in the country! Make sure you get there!!!!!Posted 10/22/13
- View all Gateway's Haunted Playhouse Reviews