Definately the Scariest on Long Island, these guys are good. Blows away the Scream Park at other end of town.
Great job and well worth the wait!

Not so great. Still too many kids as actors. I heard they have had problems opening because it was unsafe.

Hard to believe a small number if dedicated volentiers can creat such detialed sets, and build thier own props that rival any I have ever seen.

it was better a few years ago. it was just average but they are making less of an effort now

The best on long island. I've been to all long island halloween attractions and Bayville FD is THE best!! It's set to be a scary funhouse trip to hell w/ great actors and props. The actors are interactive w/ you during each scene. There is no pushing you quickly out of a room-truly scary!!

I've been going for almost 5 years or more and I know its the best Haunted Fire House anywhere!! I make sure I tell everyone about it!! The theme park down the street from the fire house can not compare!! Keep up the Great Work!! I'll see you this year!!

I'm from Manhattan. This was my first time experiencing haunted house in LI and this was the best attraction I had ever seen. The FD did an excellent job. It's an affordable price and very worthwhile.I would visit there again next year.

I went to this haunted house with my family.I went in the whole haunted house with my family and it freaked everybody out.It was the best haunted house I had ever been to in my entire life!...

Wondrefull tme great cast and props awsome job guys!!

This was truly a worthwhile time and I loved it. I went with a couple of friends to the Bayville Haunted Firehouse and I was scared out of my mind. I never get scared, ever! I especially loved the part where you go into the hospital and it's suppossed to be possessed doctors. They grabbed my jacket and wouldn't let me leave! I screamed like there was no tomorrow :) The price is great especially for what you are getting out of it.

Un-beatable... You will be talking about it for years. Scary and entertaining the entire time.

We drove a total of 50 miles to see what all the hubub was about. TRUST me its worth it! I really can't say I even remember most of it. I believe it's my body mechanism to block out the level of fright I experienced. That monster that got electrocuted scared the &*#@ out of me.
This is hands down the best Haunted house on Long Island. I want to go back! (Girls don't wear cute shoes)

You have got to come to this place! It is so scary! I would recemend to come in a large group. I did :) Me and my friends where screaming the entire time. one of them almost peed themselves. Its so woth the 10 bucks. It looks really scary from the outside but in the inside....... ITS EVEN MORE SCARY!!! Oh and if you dont like things popping out at every corner well then.... just suck it up and go in this thing!

Every year gets better then the last. the stories are true, Ive been to plenty of haunted houses but none can compareee! Dont be discouraged by the line it is sooo worth the wait!!!!

i wentt here last night(10-17-09) anddd it was OKAY. if you get scared easily, youll get the crap scared out of you. but if you dont, youll have a bad time. i went in a group of 8, and they all let us in. it was about a half hour wait, and it opens at 6. so i highly suggest you get there a half hour before. the rooms couldve been better and same with the actors. there wasnt even a guy with a chainsaw who chased you. there was a christmas room where the santa would not leave you alone but mostly they just stood there and like screamed at you, but unlike my friends, who almost started crying, they had a good time, and so did i, and the fee wasnt that bad either so all out i enjoyed it. it wasnt terrifying scary, but i had a good time.

With 15 years running, my family and I are still impressed with how scary this place is and what great efforts by the community. Well worth the wait which is entertaining as well as worth the money.

Drove from suffolk county. WOW best time I ever had in a spook house. This is A must go Firehouse. My family was scared to death. I dont scare easisly and I sure was screaming. BAYVILLE HAUNTED FIRE HOUSE A++++++. REFRESHMENTS BEFORE AND AFTER FOR (SMALL FEES) A GREAT PLUS ALSO. LOVED IT. PLEASE GO ALL.

so scary

I was a little nervous while waiting on a short line last night that we would be disappointed.
Well I wasn't disappointed at all. They let us in one group at a time and I just went with one friend so we actually got our own personal show. (This was great because there are many that come with young children) My friend and I literally peed a drop or two they scared us so much. At one point I was so scared I ran through 2 or 3 rooms screaming.

I would recomend this place as one of the best in on Long Island for sure;)

I went last year for my friend's b-day party scared the hell outa me! THEY DO TOUCH YOU!!!!! When I first walked in this lady stared grabbing me and shaking me seriously she was saying "this is the beginning of your first nightmare"! I started crying so much SUGGESTION: DON"T CRY THEY WILL SCARE U EVEN MORE!!!!!!! overall so much better then the scream park

I heard about Bayville through word of mouth and rumor had it it was amazing. I decided to go with my best friend to check it out, and boy I didn't regret it! We got there at about 6:15 and there was already a huge line. We waited for 20-30 minutes but it was worth it. It was incredible elaborate! We got into the house to wait on the line and the firehouse looks modest on the outside, but the inside was incredible! The scene is elaborate and realistic, and even before you get into the actual attraction, there are people scaring you. When we got to go inside, I was awed, if not fearful. It was even more elaborate, and not even one minute in, there were people coming out of the dark to grab at us or to scare us. Each room has its own theme and its very very real. You get touched and jumped out at, so this is not for the faint of heart. I ended up screaming so much I didn't hear anything else. They really get the best of you, it's creepy! I had a great time, it was worth the ride out to Bayville and the wait! I can't wait to do it again next year.

the merrick fire house was the best i have ever been 2

I am an actor at the haunted house. it is not only fun and scary to go through but the behind the scenes are even cooler. anyone who is willing to be scared should definately come here and all profits go to new firefighting equipment. help save a life and have fun too at Bayville haunted firehouse

Each room was amazing. The staff was great. This was the best haunted house I have been to. Looking forward to going next Halloween!

this is soooooooooooo scary but they do touch u and when i first walk in i was covering my eyes and this lady grabbed me from my freinds mom they say they don't touch you but they really do, and you have to go through this really small tunnel and people start touching you feel chlostrophobic.